I've been smoking pork shoulder for about six years now, and have fallen in love with an applewood smoke-infused pulled pork doused in a carolina vinegar style sauce. But in recent cold months I've found it difficult to get the smoker up and running at a consistant temperature, so I thought I'd enter the realm of preparing pulled pork indoors. Armed with my wife's slow cooker (and hundreds of online recipes), I was determined to keep it simple but offer a relatively good winter substitute for the real deal. While the net result lacks the smoke flavor I love, in total its still a pretty killer pulled sandwich. Here's what i did:
Most recipe's called for a 3-4 lb boneless pork shoulder. Now I've always smoked bone-in shoulders, subscribing to the camp that meat cooked on a bone has more flavor than meat cooked off the bone... but considering this needs to fit in a smaller space, I figure I'll give boneless a shot. Turns out, every spot near me in Brooklyn only sells bone-in. My local butcher could get me a 3 lb boneless shoulder next week, but he had three pieces totaling 3.5 pounds on hand. I figure I'm going to pull the whole thing anyway and snatch them up.I decided the first step should be the same as usual, and prepared a brine of brown sugar + salt, and let it sit overnight:
The next morning I drained the meat on a cooling rack (first time i've done that, but its going to be a new part of my regular process. It works beautifully!):
I then coated all pieces liberally with my standard pork bbq rub:
Now came the time to make a decision. Many slow cooker recipe's call for searing a cut of meat first, and then dropping it in the cooker. While I'm worried about searing a rubbed meat with sugar, I figure I'll give it a shot because my favorite bites of smoked pork are the crust where the rub has caramelized to black packing an insanely powerful spice and smoke explosion. So I set to searing:
...but within a few minutes have a smoke filled house causing uncontrollable coughing to anyone entering it's confines. Crap. The rub is burning:
Figuring there's no turning back at this point, I continue with the process and set the partially burnt pork slabs into the cooker:
Into the skillet I then toss a little apple cider and cider vinegar, thinking I'll scrape up some good pan drippings in the process. Then it hits me that those pan drippings are burnt. Crap 2. So I strain the liquid over a measuring cup, and end up with a 2/3rds of a cup of liquid (sans burnt chips) and toss it in the slow cooker with the pork, cover, and set it on low for 10 hrs.
As the day progresses, the house begins to loose its cough-inducing quality, and is instead filled with an increasingly warming smell of pork and spice. After 10 hours, I find three pieces of pork which are incredibly moist, practically shredding themselves:
So i set to pulling:
At this point I skimmed as much fat as possible from the juices left in the cooker, and mixed the remaining liquid in with the pulled pork. The pork alone has a very subtle flavor, but when mixed with the cooking liquid the flavor really starts to pop. Then its just a simple assembly line of cole slaw, pulled pork, and my carolina red sauce all piled into my favorite pulled meat vehicle, the hot dog bun:
Here are a few shots of the final plates:
I was really surprised by how much i liked this pulled pork. The missing smoke was, well,
MISSED, but in the end the flavors of the rub and cider, combined with the slaw and carolina sauce really created a close second to my regular version. This was definitely better than most generic pulled pork sandwiches you get at any bar/pub, and got me kind of excited to try it again. The only thing I'll do differently is skip the searing process altogether. Since i never moved the meat while it cooked, it formed a bit of a crust anyway... and i might try to amplify it a bit next time by roasting it for 15 minutes after i remove it from the slow cooker. I'm not ready to share a recipe for this sucker yet as it needs a little perfecting, but I'm confident I've got a close runner up to a smoked pulled pork, and it'll be mad easy to make.